Melodic shapes by verse classification

Verses without ole veyored or atnah can take on these shapes. Even for the simplest of verse types, reducing the complexity is impossible. The search for rules around accent sequences has no end. What we need is the music. I have serious disagreements with Flender's approaches. I think it is an academic problem. I.e. the surrounding of a complex study with methodology to the confusion of arriving at the goal of deciphering the original music. I have most certainly not given him his due. I find the approach too cumbersome and lacking in a useful result. Here is some of the raw irreducible data.

If anyone would like a file with all the Bible in this form by book, chapter and verse, please let me know. I use it for quick searches of the accents.

Movement from tonic to tonic in a single colon verse 1-1

16	e f# rev,f# e
11	e rev,f# e
10	e B g f# rev,f# e
8	e f# e rev,f# e
8	e g f# rev,f# e
8	g f# rev,f# e
4	e B g f# rev,B e
4	e ill,e ill,e
4	e ill,ill,e
3	e B g e rev,f# e
3	e B g rev,f# e
3	e g f# rev,B e
3	ger-rev,f# e
2	C g f# rev,f# e
2	e f# rev,B e
2	e g f# rev,e f# e
2	e paz,g B e
2	g B e
2	g e f# rev,f# e
2	g f# rev,B e
1	B g f# rev,e
1	B g rev,f# e
1	C B g f# rev,f# e
1	C B tsi,C f# rev,zar,C e ill,e
1	C e rev,f# e
1	C rev,g e f# rev,f# e
1	e B g e rev,e
1	e B g f# rev,e
1	e C B g f# rev,e
1	e C B g f# rev,f# e
1	e C C rev,e zar,C e rev,e
1	e C f# rev,e f# rev,f# e
1	e C g f# rev,f# e
1	e C qad,d paz,C qad,ill,rev,g f# rev,e
1	e C qad,ill,rev,B g rev,e
1	e C qad,paz,C C rev,B g rev,e
1	e C qad,paz,C e rev,B g e rev,e
1	e C qad,rev,B g f# rev,e
1	e C shl,ill,e ger-rev,e
1	e C shl,zar,C e rev,e
1	e C zar,C rev,e f# rev,e
1	e f# e rev,B e
1	e g B e
1	e g f# e rev,f# e
1	e g f# ger-rev,zar,f# e
1	e g rev,B e
1	e g rev,f# e
1	e ill,qad,rev,e zar,C e rev,B e
1	e paz,f# ger-rev,e
1	e paz,f# ger-rev,f# e
1	e paz,zar,C rev,g f# rev,f# e
1	e qad,g f# rev,B e
1	e qad,ill,rev,e f# rev,e
1	e rev,B g f# rev,f# e
1	e rev,e B g rev,f# e
1	e rev,e g f# rev,f# e
1	e rev,f# e rev,f# e
1	e zar,C shl,zar,C rev,f# e
1	f# ger,e
1	f# zar,C qad,rev,e f# rev,e
1	g f# e rev,f# e
1	g f# rev,e
1	rev,C f# tsi,d f# paz,B g qad,ill,e
1	rev,g f# e rev,B e
1	zar,C g f# rev,e
1	zar,C qad,rev,f# rev,e
1	zar,C qad,rev,zar,C e rev,e
1	zar,C qad,zar,C rev,g f# rev,zar,f# e

Distinct approaches to the ole-veyored 1-2

6	e tsi,d ole,
4	e f# rev,ole,
3	e rev,ole,
2	e C f# tsi,d ole,
2	e C qad,tsi,d ole,
2	e ill,qad,tsi,d ole,
1	C d paz,C rev,tsi,d e ole,
1	C d paz,f# rev,tsi,d ole,
1	C e tsi,d ole,
1	C f# f# rev,ole,
1	C f# rev,e ole,
1	C qad,ill,qad,rev,C qad,tsi,rev,f# ole,
1	C qad,tsi,d ole,
1	e B tsi,f# rev,ole,
1	e B tsi,ole,
1	e C B e tsi,d ole,
1	e C B tsi,e ole,
1	e C e B tsi,C ole,
1	e C f# rev,ole,
1	e C f# tsi,ole,
1	e C ill,rev,tsi,d ole,
1	e C qad,tsi,f# rev,ole,
1	e C zar,C rev,tsi,d ole,
1	e f# rev,e ole,
1	e f# tsi,C ole,
1	e f# tsi,e d ole,
1	e rev,e ole,
1	e rev,f# tsi,d ole,
1	e rev,tsi,d e ole,
1	e tsi,d e ole,
1	e zar,C qad,rev,tsi,d ole,
1	f# rev,ole,

Distinct approaches to the atnah -- only the most frequent since there are 500 of them 1-4

313	g B ^A
308	e B B ^A
242	e f# ^A
194	e B g B ^A
174	e B g ^A
101	e g B ^A
42	B g B ^A
28	e rev,g B ^A
24	e f# e ^A
24	e rev,f# ^A
20	C B B ^A
19	B g ^A
19	e C B B ^A
18	e g ^A
17	e B g e ^A
14	e C B g B ^A
13	e g f# ^A
12	B B ^A
12	g e B ^A
10	C B g B ^A
8	e ill,B B ^A
7	e B e B ^A
7	e C B g ^A
7	e f# rev,ole,f# f# ^A
7	e f# rev,ole,f# g B ^A
7	e rev,B g B ^A
7	e tsi,d ole,f# g B ^A
6	e g e ^A
6	e rev,B g ^A
6	g B B ^A
6	g B e ^A
6	zar,C B B ^A
5	B g e ^A
5	C B g ^A
5	e B e g B ^A
5	e C ill,rev,g B ^A
5	e C rev,B g ^A
5	e C rev,g B ^A
5	e f# rev,ole,f# B B ^A
5	e rev,B B ^A
5	f# ^A
4	e B g f# ^A
4	e B tsi,d ole,f# B g B ^A
4	e C g f# ^A
4	e C rev,f# ^A
4	e rev,ole,f# f# ^A
4	e rev,ole,f# g B ^A
4	e zar,C B B ^A
4	f# qad,g B ^A
4	rev,e ole,f# g B ^A
4	rev,f# ^A
4	zar,C B g B ^A
3	C f# rev,ole,f# f# ^A
3	e B B e ^A
3	e C ill,rev,f# ^A
3	e C qad,B g B ^A
3	e C qad,e rev,B B ^A
3	e C qad,e rev,g B ^A
3	e C qad,rev,f# ^A
3	e C qad,rev,g B ^A
3	e C rev,B B ^A
3	e C zar,C rev,g B ^A
3	e e B B ^A
3	e e f# ^A
3	e f# rev,ole,f# B g B ^A
3	e f# rev,ole,f# e f# ^A
3	e f# tsi,d ole,f# B g B ^A
3	e ill,B g B ^A
3	e rev,f# e ^A
3	e rev,ole,f# B g B ^A
3	e tsi,d ole,f# B g ^A
3	e zar,C B g B ^A
3	g f# ^A
3	zar,C B g ^A
3	zar,C qad,rev,f# ^A
3	zar,C qad,rev,g B ^A
2	B g e B ^A
2	C B g e ^A
2	C qad,B B ^A
2	C qad,B g B ^A
2	C qad,B tsi,d ole,f# f# ^A
2	C qad,C rev,g B ^A
2	C qad,tsi,d ole,f# B g B ^A
2	C tsi,d ole,f# g B ^A
2	e B e g ^A
2	e B g e B ^A
2	e B tsi,d ole,f# B B ^A
2	e B tsi,d ole,f# f# ^A
2	e B tsi,e ole,f# B B ^A
2	e C B tsi,d ole,f# B B ^A
2	e C B tsi,d ole,f# B g B ^A
2	e C e rev,f# ^A
2	e C f# tsi,d ole,f# g B ^A
2	e C ill,rev,B g B ^A
2	e C ill,rev,e f# ^A
2	e C qad,B g ^A
2	e C qad,e tsi,d ole,f# f# ^A
2	e C qad,tsi,d ole,f# B B ^A
2	e C qad,zar,C rev,B B ^A
2	e C qad,zar,C rev,g B ^A
2	e C zar,C rev,e f# ^A
2	e f# rev,e ole,f# e f# ^A
2	e f# rev,e ole,f# f# ^A
2	e f# rev,ole,f# B g ^A
2	e f# tsi,d ole,f# C e ^A
2	e f# tsi,d ole,f# g B ^A
2	e ill,qad,e rev,g B ^A
2	e ill,qad,rev,B B ^A
2	e ill,qad,tsi,e d ole,f# B e g B ^A
2	e qad,B g B ^A
2	e qad,B g ^A
2	e qad,e rev,e f# ^A
2	e qad,e rev,g B ^A
2	e qad,f# ^A
2	e qad,rev,B B ^A
2	e qad,zar,C rev,g B ^A
2	e rev,e B g B ^A
2	e rev,e f# ^A
2	e rev,ole,f# B g ^A
2	e rev,tsi,d e ole,f# g B ^A
2	e tsi,d ole,f# B B ^A
2	e tsi,d ole,f# B g B ^A
2	e tsi,d ole,f# e f# ^A
2	e zar,C B g ^A
2	f# B tsi,d ole,f# B g B ^A
2	f# e ^A
2	g ^A
2	g e ^A
2	rev,e ole,f# f# ^A
2	zar,C qad,e rev,g B ^A
2	zar,C qad,rev,B B ^A
2	zar,C qad,rev,e ole,f# B g B ^A
1	B e g ^A
1	B g B e ^A
1	C B ^A
1	C B e B ^A
1	C B tsi,C e ole,f# f# ^A
1	C B tsi,C ole,f# f# ^A
1	C B tsi,d e ole,f# B B ^A

Distinct moves from ole veyored to the atnah 46 rows 2-4

68	ole,f# f# ^A
55	ole,f# g B ^A
33	ole,f# B B ^A
29	ole,f# B g B ^A
21	ole,f# B g ^A
20	ole,f# e f# ^A
8	ole,f# e g B ^A
5	ole,f# ^A
4	ole,f# C B B ^A
4	ole,f# C B g B ^A
4	ole,f# e B B ^A
3	ole,f# B g e ^A
3	ole,f# C e ^A
3	ole,f# C ill,rev,f# ^A
3	ole,f# rev,g B ^A
2	ole,f# B e g B ^A
2	ole,f# B g f# ^A
2	ole,f# e ^A
2	ole,f# e rev,g B ^A
1	ole,f# C e paz,e rev,f# ^A
1	ole,f# C ill,rev,C B B ^A
1	ole,f# C qad,B g ^A
1	ole,f# C qad,e rev,f# e ^A
1	ole,f# C qad,f# rev,C B B ^A
1	ole,f# C qad,ill,rev,f# e ^A
1	ole,f# C qad,rev,f# rev,f# ^A
1	ole,f# C qad,rev,g B ^A
1	ole,f# C rev,B B ^A
1	ole,f# e B g ^A
1	ole,f# e g ^A
1	ole,f# e ill,f# ^A
1	ole,f# e paz,C qad,e rev,g B ^A
1	ole,f# e qad,rev,g B ^A
1	ole,f# e rev,e g B ^A
1	ole,f# e rev,f# ^A
1	ole,f# e rev,zar,f# f# ^A
1	ole,f# f# e ^A
1	ole,f# f# f# ^A
1	ole,f# g B C ^A
1	ole,f# g e B ^A
1	ole,f# ill,B g B ^A
1	ole,f# ill,qad,rev,B B ^A
1	ole,f# paz,zar,C rev,B B ^A
1	ole,f# rev,B B ^A
1	ole,f# rev,e f# ^A
1	ole,f# zar,C B g B ^A

Distinct moves from ole-veyored to tonic 30 rows 2-1

7	ole,f# g f# rev,f# e
6	ole,f# f# rev,f# e
2	ole,f# B g e rev,B e
2	ole,f# B g f# rev,f# e
2	ole,f# e f# rev,B e
2	ole,f# g f# rev,B e
1	ole,f# B g f# rev,B e
1	ole,f# B g f# rev,zar,f# e
1	ole,f# B g rev,e
1	ole,f# B g rev,rev,f# e
1	ole,f# C e shl,ill,e ill,e
1	ole,f# C g f# rev,f# e
1	ole,f# C paz,B g f# rev,e
1	ole,f# C qad,e g f# rev,e
1	ole,f# C qad,rev,f# rev,e
1	ole,f# C rev,C qad,g f# rev,f# e
1	ole,f# C rev,e f# e
1	ole,f# e B g f# rev,B e
1	ole,f# e f# rev,f# e
1	ole,f# e g qad,ill,e
1	ole,f# e rev,B g f# rev,B e
1	ole,f# f# e rev,B e
1	ole,f# f# rev,zar,f# e
1	ole,f# g f# rev,e
1	ole,f# g f# rev,e f# e
1	ole,f# paz,B g f# rev,f# e
1	ole,f# paz,f# ger-rev,e
1	ole,f# paz,g qad,ill,e
1	ole,f# rev,g f# rev,f# e
1	ole,f# zar,C qad,rev,g f# rev,f# e

Distinct moves from atnah to tonic 101 rows 4-1

416	^A g B e
367	^A ger-rev,f# e
361	^A ger-rev,e
183	^A ger-rev,B e
179	^A f# ger-rev,e
142	^A f# ger-rev,f# e
93	^A f# ger-rev,B e
74	^A f# e
62	^A e f# e
45	^A ger-rev,e f# e
31	^A e ger-rev,e
30	^A e g B e
26	^A e f# ger-rev,e
19	^A e ger-rev,f# e
18	^A shl,g B e
17	^A e f# ger-rev,f# e
16	^A ger-rev,C ill,e
15	^A C g B e
13	^A e f# ger-rev,B e
13	^A e ger-rev,B e
13	^A g e B e
12	^A ger,e
9	^A f# f# ger-rev,f# e
9	^A f# ger-rev,e f# e
8	^A C e g B e
7	^A e qad,g B e
7	^A f# ger,e
7	^A ger,e rev,e
7	^A qad,g B e
6	^A ger,f# rev,e
5	^A e ger,e
5	^A e ger,f# e
5	^A f# f# ger-rev,e
5	^A ger,e rev,f# e
5	^A zar,C g B e
4	^A e B e
4	^A f# e ger-rev,e
4	^A f# e ger-rev,f# e
4	^A ger,B e
3	^A C f# g B e
3	^A f# f# ger-rev,B e
3	^A f# ger-rev,C ill,e
3	^A ger,f# e
3	^A ger,f# rev,B e
3	^A ger-rev,zar,f# e
3	^A ill,g B e
2	^A C qad,g B e
2	^A e f# e ger-rev,e
2	^A e f# ger-rev,e f# e
2	^A e ger,e rev,e
2	^A e ger,g B e
2	^A e shl,g B e
2	^A f# e f# ger-rev,f# e
2	^A f# ger,B e
2	^A f# ger,e rev,e
2	^A f# ger-rev,zar,f# e
2	^A f# qad,g B e
2	^A ger,f# rev,f# e
2	^A ger-rev,e e
1	^A C e zar,f# f# ger-rev,f# e
1	^A C g e B e
1	^A e f# e ger-rev,B e
1	^A e f# e ger-rev,f# e
1	^A e f# ger,f# e
1	^A e f# ger-rev,zar,f# e
1	^A e f# rev,B e
1	^A e g e B e
1	^A e ger,B e
1	^A e ger-rev,e f# e
1	^A e ger-rev,e f# ger-rev,B e
1	^A e rev,e f# rev,B e
1	^A f# e f# e ger-rev,f# e
1	^A f# e g B e
1	^A f# e ger,e
1	^A f# e ger-rev,C ill,e
1	^A f# e zar,f# ger-rev,e
1	^A f# f# e ger-rev,B e
1	^A f# f# ger,B e
1	^A f# ger,e rev,f# e
1	^A f# ger,f# e
1	^A f# ger-rev,e g B e
1	^A f# rev,f# e
1	^A f# shl,g B e
1	^A f# zar,f# ger-rev,B e
1	^A g f# ger-rev,B e
1	^A g f# ger-rev,e
1	^A g f# ger-rev,f# e
1	^A g ger,e
1	^A ger,C ill,e
1	^A ger,e f# e
1	^A ger,e rev,e f# e
1	^A ger,e rev,f# e rev,B ^A ger-rev,e
1	^A ger-rev,B f# e
1	^A ger-rev,e g e
1	^A ill,g e B e
1	^A qad,zar,C g B e
1	^A rev,f# e
1	^A shl,C e f# e
1	^A shl,e g B e
1	^A zar,C ger-rev,e
1	^A zar,f# ger-rev,f# e
0