The theological negative

I was a singer for many years, and I was often tense as I held my music in concert. The music would gradually get higher and higher in my hands, until a friendly soprano next to me would push it down slightly and say, "Relax." Well, it's easier said than done, but I do love her and will never forget her gentle correction. I was raised with a stick as a singer. I would be punished by the priest if I sang a wrong note. It's a wonder I ever sang. But the singer in me won out for a good while. I never resolved all the tension.

The priest in question was himself a product of centuries of distortion. Part of his problem was that he had studied the King James translation of the Bible, replete with its notion of punishment. He inherited both the theology of fear and the abuse it perpetuates. His punishments were more deeply wrong than I will describe. And he forgot that he was not supposed to be the one to deliver it, -- whether we call it chastisement, or correction, or tutoring, or mentoring, all of which are glosses that bear a closer sense of the sound of the Hebrew stem.

I have reported before that there is no Hebrew stem that demands punish as a gloss, e.g. here and here and here and over seventy other places. Look at Leviticus 26. Don't imagine that there are no consequences to running off the rails. There are plenty of consequences, but listen: 

  

Leviticus 26:29 imitating the opening of Genesis. 

Genesis begins with the same E-major rising triad -- all this instruction and learning is part of being created.

The whole of Leviticus 26 is a complex of logic, and at every painful step, God walks with the people of this covenant even in their contrariness. To have God walking with you is not punishment, it is the consequence of covenant -- and  of presence. When people translate, they move rapidly from one thought to another, and may well fail, even in committee, to critique the move from cause to consequence, -- or worse, from cause to the supposed cure. 

How well does this fit with the New Testament promises? Perfect love casts out fear. The one who was before Abraham said: I am with you to the end of the age -- not to indulge your foolishness, but to keep you in all things because I cherish you. Well, I am paraphrasing of course -- and from distant memories of the NT.

We watched a live performance of E.T. the other day. (Film + live orchestra.) I heard it from one of the violinists that it is an impossible-to-read score -- no key signature, but every note with accidentals, and often spelled differently. It was a moving performance. The Bible also has no key signature.