| 1 ♪g I love, for Yahweh heard, the voice of my supplication. (g-4-1) |
|||
| א א֭הבתי כי־ישמ֥ע ׀ יהו֑ה את־ק֝ול֗י תחנונֽי |
8 7 |
a ahbti ci-iwmy ihvh at-qoli tknunii |
|
For there is a language of flowers
for flowers are peculiarly, the poetry of Christ (Christopher Smart)
א ב ג ד ה ו ז ח ט י כ ל מ נ ס ע פ צ ק ר ש ת
Pages
Tuesday, 17 November 2026
Five words
Friday, 9 October 2026
Some explanation of Zarqa and Tsinnorit - The Unicode History
This is one of the most famous, notorious mix-ups in the history of the Unicode Hebrew block, and biblicists, typographers, and software engineers have been wrestling with it for nearly three decades.
1. The Unicode Inversion Trap
- In the 21 Prose Books: The accent called Zarqa (זַרְקָא) is strictly postpositive. Because Hebrew reads right-to-left, "postpositive" means it must appear at the end of the word—hanging over the far left edge of the final consonant (or off its left shoulder).
- In the 3 Poetic Books (Sifrei Emet): The mark called Tsinnor (צִנּוֹר) or Tsinnorit (צִנּוֹרִית)—sometimes called poetic zarqa—is centered directly over the consonant of the accented syllable.
-
U+0598
was given the name HEBREW ACCENT ZARQA, but Unicode assigned it Canonical Combining Class
230(Above—centered over the letter). -
U+05AE
was given the name HEBREW ACCENT ZINOR, but Unicode assigned it Canonical Combining Class
228(Above_Left—postpositive on the left). - Because the Unicode Consortium operates under a strict Character Name Stability Policy, once a character name is published, it can never be changed or renamed. As a result:
-
U+0598is permanently stuck with the nameZARQA, even though typographically and historically its centered glyph belongs to poetic tsinnorit. -
U+05AEis permanently stuck with the nameZINOR, even though typographically its left-aligned postpositive placement is what prose zarqa actually requires.
0598 = tsinorit, zinor), but digital databases (including the Westminster Leningrad Codex,
Michigan-Claremont, and tanach.us) had to make tricky engineering
choices about which code point to store for which accent.
2. Why It Is not Easily Reproducible in a Dialogue
- Standard operating system UI fonts (Segoe UI on Windows, SF Pro on macOS, Roboto on Android) only have basic Hebrew alphabet support. They lack the advanced OpenType GPOS (Glyph Positioning) anchor tables needed for biblical diacritics.
-
In a plain dialogue box, the browser's text shaper treats both
U+0598andU+05AEas generic non-spacing combining marks. It simply averages their bounding boxes and dumps both glyphs smack in the center of the letter (or awkwardly collides them with the consonant), erasing the distinction between centered and postpositive-left.
U+05AE
over to the far left shoulder of the Alef while keeping U+0598
dead-center.
3. How This Does Not Impact the Music
-
זַרְקָא
zarqa**
(
U+0598/1432): a turn over the centre of the letter, with musical contour formula (-1+1-0), confined to poetry. In Aleppo, the prose occurrences drop to zero. -
צִנּוֹר
tsinnor
(
U+05AE/1454): a turn over the left side of the letter, with musical contour formula (-0-1+1).
ornament_usage_by_pitch.html, maintaining them as two distinct rows:
-
TSINNOR
(
U+05AE/א֮) — dominant across the canon (1,204 occurrences) -
ZARQA
(
U+0598/א֘) — poetic centered turn (144 occurrences)
Considering what the Hebrew Bible is about
I have been learning Hebrew by translating Tanach these past 20 years. What have I learned? It's always a stretch to really answer a question like this. Sometime ago, perhaps a week or a few days ago -- I forgot to look at the date, I selected Psalm 11 for a demonstration of a book idea I did not pursue -- to much at once! So I put this chapter below.
I think we can and must take the world as it is, a serious decision about what is good. And variety and trouble are part of that good. As the spiritual goes -- nobody knows de trouble a've seen... I notice that the musical contour is the same for Genesis 1:1a as it is for Verses in the story of Cain -- what have you done! And the contour is an inclusio for the deluge -- as you can discover.
The Hebrew Bible is an act of love, by humans for humans in a Spirit of
Persistence of Love, a Holiness to be sought, and a Forming of Communities of
Love in truth and kindness and faithfulness.
Let's set that against this psalm.
Trope in full is here to listen to as you read. A link on that page will take you to the verse by verse learning page.
Psalms 11
Syllables: 150. Words: 68. Roots: 52. Root Recurrence: 38%. Average per verse: 3.7.
Psalms 11: Syllables: 154; Longest recitation: 10; Tenor: f# 25.32%;
Ornament density: 15.6%; Average phrase length: 9.1.
|
1 For the leader. Of David. In Yahweh I take refuge. How do you say to me, Flit away to your mountain, bird? (1-2-4-1) |
|||
|
א למנצ֗ח לד֫ו֥ד בֽיהו֨ה ׀ חס֗יתי א֭יך תאמר֣ו לנפש֑י נ֝֗ודי הרכ֥ם צפֽור |
7 11 6 |
a lmnxk ldvid bihvh ksiti aiç tamru lnpwi nudi hrcm xipor |
|
|
2 ♪C For behold: the wicked. They direct
a bow. They prepare their arrows on the bow-string, to shoot in gloom at the upright of heart. (C-4-1) |
|||
|
ב כ֤י הנ֪ה הרשע֡ים ידרכ֬ון ק֗שת כוננ֣ו חצ֣ם על־י֑תר ליר֥ות במו־א֝֗פל לישרי־לֽב |
18 9 |
b ci hnh hrwyim idrcun qwt connu kixm
yl-itr lirot bmo-aopl liwri-lb |
|
|
3 ♪B For the fundamentals are
overthrown. How does a righteous one work? (B-4-1) |
|||
| ג כ֣י ה֭שתות יֽהרס֑ון צ֝ד֗יק מה־פעֽל |
8 5 |
g ci hwtot iihrsun xdiq mh-pyl |
|
|
4 Yahweh is in his holy temple. Yahweh
in the heavens his throne. His eyes gaze on, His eyelids test the children of humanity. (1-2-4-1) |
|||
|
ד יהו֤ה ׀ בֽה֘יכ֤ל קדש֗ו יהוה֮ בשמ֪ים כ֫סא֥ו עינ֥יו יחז֑ו עפעפ֥יו י֝בחנ֗ו בנ֣י אדֽם |
14 5 10 |
d ihvh bhicl qodwo ihvh bwmiim cisao
yiniv ikzu ypypiv ibknu bni adm |
|
|
5 Yahweh will test a righteous one, but the wicked and lover of violence ... he hates. (1-2-4-1) |
|||
|
ה יהוה֮ צד֪יק י֫בח֥ן ו֭רשע ואה֣ב חמ֑ס שֽנא֥ה נפשֽו |
6 8 4 |
h ihvh xdiq ibkn vrwy vaohb kms wnah npwo |
|
|
6 He rains snares on the wicked. Fire and pitch and ferocious wind are the portion of their cup. (1-2-1) |
|||
|
ו ימט֥ר על־רשע֗ים פ֫ח֥ים א֣ש ו֭גפרית ור֥וח זלעפ֗ות מנ֣ת כוסֽם |
8 14 |
v imTr yl-rwyim pkim aw vgoprit vruk zlypot mnt cosm |
|
|
7 For Yahweh is a righteous one. He
loves righteousness. His faces gaze on the upright. (1-4-1) |
|||
|
ז כֽי־צד֣יק י֭הוה צדק֣ות אה֑ב י֝ש֗ר יחז֥ו פנֽימו |
9 8 |
z ci-xdiq ihvh xdqot ahb iwr ikzu pnimo |
|
| 1 |
flit away, (nvd) wander aimlessly, even sounds like English nod, flit
off is too rude for me though the sense may be that rude. your mountain, (hr) or hill. Your is plural, mountain is a metonym for God. I have used both mountain and hill for this word. |
| 3 |
fundamentals, (wit) to set. The form of the word is rare, used here
and in Isaiah 19:10, but the underlying root is very common. work, (pyl) not the word for do or make. |
| 4 | Does this one have eyelids (ypyp)? This word is rare in the Bible. It is used in Job three times. Taken together with Leviathan, it forms part of the framework of Job (with a touch of humour). It appears twice in the Psalter, here and in Psalm 132 where David says he will not let his eyelids slumber until he builds a house for his Lord. Elsewhere in the Bible, it occurs five more times, including one seductive fluttering in Proverbs 6. |
| 5 | he hates, lit. hates his being, or hates himself. Most translations consider the wicked as the object of hate belonging to Yahweh. |
| 6 | [Matthew 5:45] |
| 7 | gaze, third person plural agreeing with faces as subject. |
| Word / Gloss | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | Vs | Stem |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
לישרי at the upright of
|
▒ |
2 | ישר | |||||
יחזו gaze on |
▒ |
4 | חזה | |||||
יבחנו test |
▒ |
4 | בחן | |||||
יבחן will test |
▒ |
5 | בחן | |||||
|
ואהב and lover of
|
▒ |
5 | אהב | |||||
אהב he loves |
▒ |
7 | אהב | |||||
|
ישר the upright
|
▒ |
7 | ישר | |||||
יחזו gaze on |
▒ |
7 | חזה |
Resolving the impasse of diacritics in the Hebrew Bible
Ornament Usage by Recitation Pitch
Here is yet another replacement of an image I have been making forever. The splitting of the ornaments by their usage above and below the text is the key to the deciphering key. It reveals patterns like no other decision can. I hope you can click the image to expand it. The html itself is too wide for my blog. I am using the music to demonstrate and fix textual errors in copying between the Leningrad and Aleppo codices. It's not easy being green, as a famous frog noted. For the music and its demonstration see my GitHub workbench. For comments and explanations to the extent that they are useful, see my Substack page. And play with the verses on the site -- click the links, without cost and without price. Enjoy the word upside down. Pull the strings in the site and send feedback on what you would like to see.
The deciphering key to the musical sense of the accents separates the accents below the text (which govern recitation pitch) from those above the text (which provide melodic ornamentation relative to that pitch). Counts reflect occurrences by verse across the 24 books of the Hebrew Bible. (Occurrences by syllable are at the site).
Saturday, 5 September 2026
Analysis of Psalm 117
Saturday, 8 August 2026
A quick hello
I've been ignoring you -- very busy and not yet dead -- poor eyes, heart wobbly, but going strong with continuing to explore the music of the Hebrew Bible. The GitHub site has been updated with several features since my last post. All music available free to the general public. And features that could be used to explore the music with automation. Someone write a feature discovery program. I haven't figured out how to specify such a feature yet. But the site would be ideal for teaching the Haïk-Vantoura trope.
Recent substack posts will give you the updates. I think you can find them all here.
I looked my blog reader -- and I had over 3000 unread posts -- signed on and having a look :)
Wednesday, 15 July 2026
The surprises in Leviticus 26
Sunday, 12 July 2026
Dreams and GitHub
I dreamt this morning of a refreshed GitHub -- and it's refreshed.
Have a look here. I've let the entire Hebrew text stand on it's own and the colour display (use a wide screen) now counts the identical pieces and allows you to see at a glance the structure imposed by the te'amim onto the chapter. There are mountains of things to discover here -- it takes more than one person. So it's on GitHub -- 20 years of effort condensed into a musicological research station.
Drill down through music scores and look in the colour matrix for:
- repetitions across a chapter
- singular usage notes (e.g. Psalms 136)
- repeating idioms across multiple chapters-- more info coming
- patterns within a chapter like refrains -- e.g. the use of the hich C and so on
Friday, 3 July 2026
Using AI to analyse ancient music.
Tanakh Cantillation Analysis Suite
complete_tanakh.json) bypasses raw visual vector noise (like SVGs) and organizes the entire
corpus into a flat, chronological array. Because ancient Hebrew reads
right-to-left while Western music scales left-to-right, the database
establishes an immutable sequence track.
-
BOOK_CD/BOOK_SEQ_NO: The canonical book name and its numerical sequence identifier (ensuring Genesis is #1 and Ezra/Chronicles sit at their proper historical endpoints). -
CHAPTER_CD/VERSE_CD: Padded structural address coordinates. -
XML_SEQ: The master sequential timeline anchor. Crucial for linear right-to-left processing. -
LYRIC_SYLL: The transliterated phonetic syllable fragment. -
SYLL_NOTE: The explicit absolute pitch token (calibrated around Tonic =E4). -
ORNAMENT_NAME: Fully populated lowercase Masoretic accent tags (e.g.,atnach,ole,revia-mugrash,paz). -
HEB_TEXT: The fully pointed, unescaped Hebrew text string, anchored elegantly to the first syllable of each verse change.
G#4
present,
F#4
forbidden)
-
E4(Degree 1 - Tonic): Ground baseline and home register. -
F4(Degree 2 - Supertonic): A dynamic, kinetic bridge. Never a rest point. It acts as an acoustic pathway driving into aG#4or stepping down to the tonicE4at a verse boundary. -
G4/G#4(Degree 3 - Mediant): Signals anticipation of an impending structural cadence. -
A4(Degree 4 - Subdominant): An expansive, level plateau delivering profound equilibrium, security, and confidence (rather than Western tension). -
B4(Degree 5 - Dominant): The narrative engine; the first natural harmonic of the shofar used for royal proclamation.
F#4
present,
G#4
forbidden)
-
F#4(Degree 2 Sharp): An expressive, hovering suspension plateau. It functions as a formal, binding cadence ONLY if the previous syllable carried the lowercaseoleornament. -
G4(Degree 3 - Mediant): Elevates into a primary, high-intensity recitation engine holding deep emotional focus. -
D4(Degree 7 - Sub-Tonic): The physical springboard. A low, muscular crouching note used to gather potential energy before vertical melodic vaults. -
C5(Degree 6 - Sixth Degree): A transcendent register used for intense appeals or sudden explosions of absolute joy and awe.
Job 3:1
to
Job 4:5) by translating chapter/verse vectors into flat mathematical scalars,
preventing data bleeding at chapter boundaries.
Job 3
or
Psalm 29) where the melody shatters smooth step-wise motion. It targets verses that
launch immediately into
C5
or treat the opening tonic
E4
as a fractional, explosive upbeat rocket.
E4. By kicking off on a dominant
B4
or a tense
F#4, these verses function as a "reverse colon," forcing the performer to
aurally anchor the sentence onto the emotional residue of the preceding text.
revia-mugrash
ornament, documenting the exact pitch register it chose to lock onto as it
builds its technical runway back down to the baseline.